I read with interest and not a little dismay Bishop Sis’s article about payday lenders. I don’t deny that they’re bloodsuckers, but his analysis would have been more convincing—and accurate—if he’d used proper terminology and done some fact-checking.
He mentions payday lenders being located close to veterans’ facilities. I believe he means military facilities. He refers to “the poor financial misfortune of our veterans.” If he had checked current pay scales he’d know that a recruit earns approximately 150% of the poverty level, and when allowances are added in, it’s closer to 250% of the poverty level. I’m not begrudging military personnel a penny of what they get—I wish it were more—but to suggest military people are on the brink of starvation is grossly inaccurate.
Bishop Sis also says: “Throughout history, governments have sought to protect the poor from exploitative interest rates and consumer loans.” This is absolutely untrue. History tells us governments have been among the greatest exploiters of the poor, that until the American Revolution, governments were established by the rich to protect their interests. The concept of “We the People” being the source and repository of government power had never been tried before. Let’s not forget Magna Carta was an agreement between the nobility and the king, not between the poor and the ruling class.
Bishop Sis also refers to several studies: “...a recent Texas study...” “Approximately 75 percent of all fees...” It would be useful to know who performed these studies and supplied the data in order to gage their credibility. The adage comes to mind that “Figures don’t lie, but liars figure.”
Later, when he makes recommendations to solve or at least ameliorate the problem, I found one glaring omission. He blames payday lenders for the financial misery of military personnel. He urges expansion of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, a creation of the Dodd-Frank legislation that brought us to our knees when the sub-prime loans it mandated burst like a soapy bubble. However, Bishop Sis never addresses personal responsibility. One statistic I would have liked to see presented was the percentage of car-title loans made on Corvettes, Mercedes, BMWs and other high-end “wheels.” Why did he not recommend young and inexperienced service members be taught that they shouldn’t buy things they can’t afford, that they don’t have a “right” to all the toys in the store?
I agree completely with the bishop’s final statement: “The way we resolve this current moral challenge will demonstrate our character as a society.” Will we be a Nanny State in which we make every personal failing and bad decision a social problem, then turn to the government to protect us from our own greed and laziness? Or will we be a nation of free individuals who take personal responsibility for our mistakes and profit by the self-esteem earned in overcoming them?
Comments
...to Col (ret) Casper, I think he needs to do some more research on the figures, too.
CNN reported in February 2014 that approximately $103M worth of food stamps were redeemed at military commissaries nationwide during FY13. That only accounts for commissaries. As only military members and retirees have authorization to shop at commissaries, that tells me that we once again have a problem with military wages keeping up with the poverty level. This number does not include WIC.
I also detect the standard "stupid enlisted people buy expensive cars and get in trouble" argument. And while I certainly dealt with one or two young military members who's ego exceeded their wallet, my very recent experience has been that rarely do the folks who are in the most trouble have the "high-end 'wheels'." Usually they were mini-vans and econo-hatchbacks.
Congress attempted shield service members from predatory lenders by capping interest rates at 36%, but congress left loopholes you could drive a dump truck through (mostly by length of loan) and we're back in the same problem.
The problems are far more complex than what Col Casper presented. And a very happy Veteran's Day to one and all...
- Log in or register to post comments
Permalink- Log in or register to post comments
Permalink- Log in or register to post comments
Permalink- Log in or register to post comments
PermalinkPost a comment to this article here: